{ "$schema": "../../schema/benchmark.schema.json", "benchmark_id": "zod--claude-opus-5--bm1--2026-09-07", "preregistration": "prompts/benchmark.md", "library": { "name": "zod", "ecosystem": "npm", "graded_against": "4.5.4", "installed_on": "2026-09-07", "bisected": true, "bisect_journal": "JOURNAL/067" }, "subject": { "id": "claude-opus-5", "label": "Claude Opus 5", "vendor": "Anthropic", "invoked_as": "Agent tool subagent, model opus, one fresh subagent per cell with no memory of any other cell; the retry rounds of a cell continue that same subagent. Delivery per prompts/benchmark.md §14.", "self_reported_cutoff": null, "measured_boundary": "4.1.0", "self_test": true }, "protocol": { "date": "2026-09-07", "arms": [ { "name": "BARE", "context_file": null, "context_words": 0, "context_chars": 0 }, { "name": "PACK", "context_file": "corrections/zod.md", "context_words": 7396, "context_chars": 51247, "context_sha256": "69fdf7aef666f789fddb5bf807130342a42fc9d3226605df12fd9fd8074800c6" }, { "name": "PLACEBO", "context_file": "corrections/tailwindcss.md", "context_words": 7732, "context_chars": 57591, "context_sha256": "e11695781ff7d455d69fbfd37b41b20011e099ce9183c0819dcc24466a51966e" } ], "draws_per_arm": 2, "retry_cap": 3, "grader": "node", "class_ratio": { "A": 2, "N": 1 }, "delivery": { "mechanism": "file-read", "wrapper_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-delivery-wrapper.txt", "wrapper_sha256": "e38afc301a1d53bd9089cff2cf366729821a4a771526420be7aed377e470fba4", "tool_use_selfreport": true, "note": "The runner writes each round's exact bytes; the subject is sent this wrapper and reads that file. Rejected alternative: pasting the bytes into the spawn, which would have the operator re-emitting a 51,247-character pack from its own context 36 times, where silent drift is unfalsifiable. The wrapper is byte-identical across arms apart from the path it names, and its rendered characters are billed to every round. A correction round is delivered as the conversation so far, file by file, because this harness cannot hand a running subagent another turn: recorded in prompts/benchmark.md §14 as a correction, made after the first failing cell and before any cell had a second round.", "wrapper_retry_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-delivery-wrapper-retry.txt", "wrapper_retry_sha256": "87b0f3ab692e7d2f3cb149827b2a8e689ae003bc4a89b56ab028282fc4588ef1" }, "token_unit_note": "Characters and words are exact and complete for this sample. input_tokens and output_tokens are null throughout: the Agent-tool transport reports no provider token counts to the operator, this repo has no tokenizer and takes no dependency, and an estimated token count printed beside a measured one is a number nobody can check. B2's break-even is quoted in characters or not quoted.", "deviations": [ "PLACEBO is corrections/tailwindcss.md, not the corrections/next.js.md named in the pre-registration §5. Two reasons, recorded 2026-09-07 before any arm ran (prompts/benchmark.md §5 amendment): the next.js pack names zod three times, including two open-questions entries about model boundaries ON ZOD, so it is not a zod-free control; and §5's own size rule now selects tailwindcss, because the zod pack grew from 5,384 to 7,396 words as the data lane corrected it (tailwindcss 7,732 words, +4.5%; next.js 5,560, -24.8%).", "The subject is the same model as the operator (subject.self_test true). Disclosed rather than avoided: the studio has no independent Opus 5 to spawn." ] }, "tasks": [ { "id": "A1", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF3", "severity": "S1", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a1.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A1", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "falling", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A1.stale.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A1.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A2", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF1", "severity": "S1", "previously_charged": true, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a2.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A2", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "falling", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A2.stale.mjs", "boundary": "4.3.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A2.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A3", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF10", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a3.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A3", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A3.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A3.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.4.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A4", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF15", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": true, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a4.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A4", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A4.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.3.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A4.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.3.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A5", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF9", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": true, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a5.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A5", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A5.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A5.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.4.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A6", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF17", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a6.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A6", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A6.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.1.13", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A6.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.1.13", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A7", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF8", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": true, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a7.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A7", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A7.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A7.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.4.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A8", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF7", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": true, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a8.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A8", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A8.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.2.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A8.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.2.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A9", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF20", "severity": "S2", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a9.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A9", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A9.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.3.2", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A9.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.3.2", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A10", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF18", "severity": "S3", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a10.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A10", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A10.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A10.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.4.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A11", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF19", "severity": "S3", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a11.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A11", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A11.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.3.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A11.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.3.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "A12", "class": "A", "fact_id": "LF12", "severity": "S3", "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-a12.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "A12", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "rising", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A12.reference.mjs", "boundary": "4.4.0", "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/A12.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.4.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N1", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n1.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N1", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N1.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N1.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N2", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n2.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N2", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N2.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N2.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N3", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n3.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N3", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N3.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N3.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N4", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n4.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N4", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N4.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N4.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N5", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n5.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N5", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N5.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N5.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } }, { "id": "N6", "class": "N", "fact_id": null, "severity": null, "previously_charged": false, "prompt_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark-zod-n6.txt", "assertion": { "module": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod.mjs", "export": "N6", "kind": "exec" }, "flip_test": { "ladder": [ "4.0.0", "4.0.17", "4.1.0", "4.1.6", "4.1.13", "4.2.0", "4.2.1", "4.3.0", "4.3.1", "4.3.2", "4.3.6", "4.4.0", "4.4.3", "4.5.0", "4.5.4" ], "shape": "null", "artifact": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N6.reference.mjs", "boundary": null, "correct_reference": "tools/benchmark/tasks/zod/N6.reference.mjs", "correct_passes_from": "4.0.0", "contiguous": true } } ], "results": [ { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2321, "input_words": 356, "output_chars": 713, "output_words": 94, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2321, "input_words": 356, "output_chars": 808, "output_words": 109, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53575, "input_words": 7753, "output_chars": 885, "output_words": 118, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53575, "input_words": 7753, "output_chars": 829, "output_words": 113, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59922, "input_words": 8089, "output_chars": 1131, "output_words": 148, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A1", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59922, "input_words": 8089, "output_chars": 1134, "output_words": 160, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a1-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1729, "input_words": 286, "output_chars": 360, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1729, "input_words": 286, "output_chars": 999, "output_words": 162, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52983, "input_words": 7683, "output_chars": 926, "output_words": 141, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52983, "input_words": 7683, "output_chars": 604, "output_words": 88, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59330, "input_words": 8019, "output_chars": 433, "output_words": 54, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A10", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59330, "input_words": 8019, "output_chars": 453, "output_words": 57, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a10-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1482, "input_words": 241, "output_chars": 114, "output_words": 15, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1482, "input_words": 241, "output_chars": 143, "output_words": 20, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52736, "input_words": 7638, "output_chars": 107, "output_words": 15, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52736, "input_words": 7638, "output_chars": 107, "output_words": 15, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59083, "input_words": 7974, "output_chars": 143, "output_words": 20, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A11", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59083, "input_words": 7974, "output_chars": 314, "output_words": 49, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a11-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1852, "input_words": 299, "output_chars": 824, "output_words": 131, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1852, "input_words": 299, "output_chars": 981, "output_words": 157, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53106, "input_words": 7696, "output_chars": 825, "output_words": 137, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53106, "input_words": 7696, "output_chars": 1015, "output_words": 166, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59453, "input_words": 8032, "output_chars": 879, "output_words": 147, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A12", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59453, "input_words": 8032, "output_chars": 1012, "output_words": 170, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a12-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2386, "input_words": 367, "output_chars": 945, "output_words": 128, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2386, "input_words": 367, "output_chars": 1463, "output_words": 219, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53640, "input_words": 7764, "output_chars": 810, "output_words": 102, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53640, "input_words": 7764, "output_chars": 817, "output_words": 107, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 1, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59987, "input_words": 8100, "output_chars": 917, "output_words": 112, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "TypeError: Booking.innerType is not a function", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" }, { "round": 1, "input_chars": 62255, "input_words": 8414, "output_chars": 1523, "output_words": 219, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d1.round1.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d1.round1.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A2", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59987, "input_words": 8100, "output_chars": 1594, "output_words": 213, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a2-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1792, "input_words": 296, "output_chars": 224, "output_words": 26, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1792, "input_words": 296, "output_chars": 642, "output_words": 88, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53046, "input_words": 7693, "output_chars": 265, "output_words": 38, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53046, "input_words": 7693, "output_chars": 580, "output_words": 89, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59393, "input_words": 8029, "output_chars": 718, "output_words": 104, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A3", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59393, "input_words": 8029, "output_chars": 717, "output_words": 97, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a3-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2054, "input_words": 321, "output_chars": 1149, "output_words": 165, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2054, "input_words": 321, "output_chars": 1148, "output_words": 166, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53308, "input_words": 7718, "output_chars": 213, "output_words": 23, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53308, "input_words": 7718, "output_chars": 213, "output_words": 23, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59655, "input_words": 8054, "output_chars": 1073, "output_words": 147, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A4", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59655, "input_words": 8054, "output_chars": 1433, "output_words": 205, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a4-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1859, "input_words": 298, "output_chars": 1808, "output_words": 271, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1859, "input_words": 298, "output_chars": 1060, "output_words": 160, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53113, "input_words": 7695, "output_chars": 1025, "output_words": 154, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53113, "input_words": 7695, "output_chars": 1202, "output_words": 177, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "Bash", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ], "excluded": true, "note": "Excluded from every aggregate under prompts/benchmark.md §14: the subject self-reported TOOLS_USED: Bash, so it did not answer under the no-tools condition every other cell answered under. The cell stays published with its reply and its verdict (pass, round 0). The operator cannot see a subagent tool call, so this exclusion rests on the subject having reported it." }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59460, "input_words": 8031, "output_chars": 2495, "output_words": 362, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A5", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59460, "input_words": 8031, "output_chars": 1478, "output_words": 213, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a5-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 3, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1975, "input_words": 325, "output_chars": 1067, "output_words": 147, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" }, { "round": 1, "input_chars": 4432, "input_words": 678, "output_chars": 2101, "output_words": 315, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round1.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round1.reply.txt" }, { "round": 2, "input_chars": 8088, "input_words": 1203, "output_chars": 1599, "output_words": 252, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"under_score_case\") returned \"underscorecase\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"under-score-case\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round2.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round2.reply.txt" }, { "round": 3, "input_chars": 11422, "input_words": 1668, "output_chars": 1684, "output_words": 255, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round3.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d1.round3.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 3, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1975, "input_words": 325, "output_chars": 2117, "output_words": 329, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" }, { "round": 1, "input_chars": 5482, "input_words": 860, "output_chars": 2907, "output_words": 460, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round1.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round1.reply.txt" }, { "round": 2, "input_chars": 9944, "input_words": 1530, "output_chars": 1795, "output_words": 272, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"under_score_case\") returned \"underscorecase\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"under-score-case\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round2.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round2.reply.txt" }, { "round": 3, "input_chars": 13474, "input_words": 2015, "output_chars": 1843, "output_words": 263, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round3.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-bare-d2.round3.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53229, "input_words": 7722, "output_chars": 594, "output_words": 95, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53229, "input_words": 7722, "output_chars": 178, "output_words": 25, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 3, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59576, "input_words": 8058, "output_chars": 2270, "output_words": 327, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" }, { "round": 1, "input_chars": 63245, "input_words": 8591, "output_chars": 3322, "output_words": 506, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round1.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round1.reply.txt" }, { "round": 2, "input_chars": 68137, "input_words": 9307, "output_chars": 3363, "output_words": 522, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round2.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round2.reply.txt" }, { "round": 3, "input_chars": 73241, "input_words": 10043, "output_chars": 4643, "output_words": 725, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round3.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d1.round3.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A6", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 3, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59576, "input_words": 8058, "output_chars": 1527, "output_words": 226, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" }, { "round": 1, "input_chars": 62502, "input_words": 8490, "output_chars": 2161, "output_words": 322, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"Héllo Wörld\") returned \"hello-world\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"hllo-wrld\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round1.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round1.reply.txt" }, { "round": 2, "input_chars": 66233, "input_words": 9022, "output_chars": 1074, "output_words": 155, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": false, "feedback": "Slug.parse(\"under_score_case\") returned \"underscorecase\"; zod's own slug transform returns \"under-score-case\"", "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round2.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round2.reply.txt" }, { "round": 3, "input_chars": 69063, "input_words": 9390, "output_chars": 1614, "output_words": 231, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round3.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a6-placebo-d2.round3.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1947, "input_words": 285, "output_chars": 2062, "output_words": 289, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1947, "input_words": 285, "output_chars": 1660, "output_words": 238, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53201, "input_words": 7682, "output_chars": 94, "output_words": 15, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53201, "input_words": 7682, "output_chars": 760, "output_words": 124, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59548, "input_words": 8018, "output_chars": 2298, "output_words": 341, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A7", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59548, "input_words": 8018, "output_chars": 2074, "output_words": 309, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a7-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1555, "input_words": 252, "output_chars": 808, "output_words": 126, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1555, "input_words": 252, "output_chars": 657, "output_words": 103, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52809, "input_words": 7649, "output_chars": 844, "output_words": 130, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 52809, "input_words": 7649, "output_chars": 195, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59156, "input_words": 7985, "output_chars": 695, "output_words": 94, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A8", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "abandoned", "pass": null, "rounds_to_pass": null, "rounds": [], "note": "Abandoned, not graded, counted in no aggregate. The subject replied and the reply reached the operator, but saving it introduced a U+25A0 inside the object literal - operator transcription damage, not the subject's code - and node read it as SyntaxError: Invalid or unexpected token. The operator cannot reconstruct the bytes the subject sent, so the cell is not evidence either way and is not re-run: a cell re-drawn after its result was seen is a cell chosen by its result. The damaged reply stays on disk as prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a8-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt. tools/benchmark/run.mjs now refuses to grade a reply carrying that class of character (prompts/benchmark.md section 14)." }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2164, "input_words": 346, "output_chars": 1124, "output_words": 142, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 2164, "input_words": 346, "output_chars": 1218, "output_words": 174, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53418, "input_words": 7743, "output_chars": 1661, "output_words": 193, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53418, "input_words": 7743, "output_chars": 1125, "output_words": 149, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59765, "input_words": 8079, "output_chars": 1457, "output_words": 193, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "A9", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59765, "input_words": 8079, "output_chars": 1808, "output_words": 217, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/a9-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1894, "input_words": 306, "output_chars": 347, "output_words": 44, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1894, "input_words": 306, "output_chars": 347, "output_words": 44, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53148, "input_words": 7703, "output_chars": 1019, "output_words": 147, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53148, "input_words": 7703, "output_chars": 831, "output_words": 128, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59495, "input_words": 8039, "output_chars": 355, "output_words": 44, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N1", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59495, "input_words": 8039, "output_chars": 355, "output_words": 44, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n1-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1759, "input_words": 307, "output_chars": 362, "output_words": 40, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1759, "input_words": 307, "output_chars": 370, "output_words": 40, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53013, "input_words": 7704, "output_chars": 340, "output_words": 37, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53013, "input_words": 7704, "output_chars": 340, "output_words": 37, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59360, "input_words": 8040, "output_chars": 370, "output_words": 40, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N2", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59360, "input_words": 8040, "output_chars": 347, "output_words": 37, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n2-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1982, "input_words": 336, "output_chars": 239, "output_words": 24, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1982, "input_words": 336, "output_chars": 412, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53236, "input_words": 7733, "output_chars": 232, "output_words": 24, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53236, "input_words": 7733, "output_chars": 412, "output_words": 45, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59583, "input_words": 8069, "output_chars": 239, "output_words": 24, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N3", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59583, "input_words": 8069, "output_chars": 258, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n3-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1854, "input_words": 306, "output_chars": 544, "output_words": 61, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1854, "input_words": 306, "output_chars": 544, "output_words": 61, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53108, "input_words": 7703, "output_chars": 292, "output_words": 38, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53108, "input_words": 7703, "output_chars": 292, "output_words": 38, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59455, "input_words": 8039, "output_chars": 404, "output_words": 51, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N4", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59455, "input_words": 8039, "output_chars": 404, "output_words": 51, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n4-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1924, "input_words": 303, "output_chars": 240, "output_words": 24, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1924, "input_words": 303, "output_chars": 240, "output_words": 24, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53178, "input_words": 7700, "output_chars": 263, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53178, "input_words": 7700, "output_chars": 281, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59525, "input_words": 8036, "output_chars": 270, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N5", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59525, "input_words": 8036, "output_chars": 262, "output_words": 27, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n5-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1795, "input_words": 297, "output_chars": 346, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-bare-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-bare-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "BARE", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 1795, "input_words": 297, "output_chars": 354, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-bare-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-bare-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53049, "input_words": 7694, "output_chars": 343, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-pack-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-pack-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "PACK", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 53049, "input_words": 7694, "output_chars": 666, "output_words": 96, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-pack-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-pack-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 1, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59396, "input_words": 8030, "output_chars": 354, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-placebo-d1.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-placebo-d1.round0.reply.txt" } ] }, { "task_id": "N6", "arm": "PLACEBO", "draw": 2, "status": "graded", "pass": true, "rounds_to_pass": 0, "rounds": [ { "round": 0, "input_chars": 59396, "input_words": 8030, "output_chars": 354, "output_words": 42, "input_tokens": null, "output_tokens": null, "passed": true, "feedback": null, "tools_used": "none", "code_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-placebo-d2.round0.code.mjs", "reply_file": "prompts/sent/benchmark/bm1/n6-placebo-d2.round0.reply.txt" } ] } ], "summary": "BM1 is complete: 106 graded cells of 108 planned (one excluded for a self-reported tool use, one abandoned in transcription). Every arm passed every cell it was graded on - BARE 36/36, PACK 35/35, PLACEBO 35/35 - so the terminal pass rate does not distinguish the arms and B1, that PACK passes more Class A tasks than BARE, is falsified. Before any correction round, PACK passed 23 of 23 Class A cells against BARE 22 of 24 and PLACEBO 20 of 23. Thirteen correction rounds were spent in the entire run and twelve of them belong to one task, A6 (zod 4.1.13 own slug transform), which PACK answered at round 0 in both draws while BARE and PLACEBO each ran to the pre-registered cap. B2 is confirmed against our own product: a PACK cell cost a mean 53,733 characters against BARE 4,496, and even billing the pack once per session rather than once per task it would need about 28 fact-dependent tasks to repay itself against BARE measured retry overhead of 1,799 characters per cell, against the roughly 12 pre-registered. B3 held: PLACEBO tracked BARE rather than PACK on both pass rate and correction rounds, so the pack single measured effect is not context bulk. B4 is falsified: harm is zero, with all six Class N tasks passing in every arm at round 0. B5 holds, on the strength of A6 alone.", "journal": "JOURNAL/083" }